Mercedes and Ferrari in 'secret' Pirelli tyre tests

Lunchtime/Breakfast Update

Ted Kravitz:
"The Mercedes' defence contained some key points. As far as they are concerned, they asked Charlie Whiting who then checked with the FIA legal department and who then came back to Mercedes to say that 'as long as this is run under the guise of a Pirelli test then we don't have a problem with that'.

Pirelli comes out swinging:
"we do not come under the jurisdiction or authority of the FIA".

Pirelli lawyer Dominque Dumas also argues that there are no restrictions in Pirelli's agreement with the FIA about what car can be used for its permitted tests.
 
^ And the case against Flav is why they evidently don't come under the FIAs jurisdiction. I have to say the more this goes on the more its the FIA that are coming out looking like a complete shambles.

I have to say as well, if its true that Ferrari tested at Barcelona and tested new parts then the FIAs decision not to send them to the independent tribunal (which after all is the only non-independent part of the process (if we're to believe that the tribunal is independent) ) looks absolutely stupid/borderline corrupt.
 
Some interesting details have emerged from today.

Ferrari carried out a Pirelli test last year with Felipe Massa driving.
That was completely unknown until today.

As we now know, they also carried out one this year.
It was previously believed to have been at Bahrain, but it was in fact at Spain, one week before the GP.
They did use an older car but tested some parts apparently.
If it was just a tyre test for Pirelli, what were they doing testing parts?
 
I'm still baffled about how an F1 test can happen without a single mention in the media, it only takes one person in the vicinity of, or at, the track to take a picture and post something on Facebook/Twitter/etc. A test last year that we knew nothing about until today?!
 
last years test didn't seem to help Massa much did it?

Think both teams are bang to rights if you ask me. F1 rules have always been a bit like rulers they are fun to bend but eventually someone takes it to far and the whole thing snaps but as they are easily replaceable no one ever learns from it.

If they really wanted to stop all this regs bending then they'd kick Ferrari, Merc and Red Bull (not sure what Red Bull have done yet but I'm oretty sure they'll have done something) for the rest of the season. Not only will it teach them a lesson in rules it'll cost them a lot of money and teach them that F1 can live without them when the viewing figures sky rocket as we suddenly have a close battle at the front.

Won't happen though. Ferrari will get away scott free and Merc will get a fine on the condition Ross Brawn gets the sack.
 
All is blind to those who don't see or aren't looking!.

I'm in thrall of the outcome because, whatever it is, it will still only be less than half the story. They are all conniving, competitive bastards who hide behind useless regulations and lawyers when 'caught in the headlights'.

And this fiasco is meant to show transparency!
 
The claim that Rosberg and Hamilton used plain helmets to "protect them from fans" just proves how much crap is being spouted to try and justify it.

A closed, secret test session which no-one knew about, yet the drivers had to be protected from fans?
Would that be the fans which knew nothing about it, nor were present at the circuit?
And even if they had been they wouldn't have been allowed in as the gates were locked and guarded?
 
Has either driver made a comment? Being issued the 'plain helmet' order must have rang some alarm bells that what they were doing wasn't strictly legal.

Lewis got very upset when Mclaren asked him to lie. This seems a very similar situation.
 
I have been thinking exactly the same thing - wrong place, wrong time again for Hamilton.

This sums it up for me:

Christian Horner said:
"I think there's a degree of ambiguity but the rules are very clear. All the teams know what the rules are, they spend an awful lot of time involved in writing the rules with the FIA, so I think all the teams are quite clear on what the rules are."
 
Yeah, the black helmet thing is the funniest aspect of the whole saga for me:

Mercedes said it regretted - and apologised for - the decision to have race drivers Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg wear plain black helmets at the test.

"We had our reasons," said Harris. "It was about the lack of bodyguard and security personnel. We do acknowledge that this part of the test aroused suspicions and it is regrettable."

Bull and may I add Shit !!! ROFL

In that case, you would expect Lewis or Nico to wear black crash helmets doing street runs, at the Goodwood festival of speed, doing straight line tests on an air field, in fact, just about anywhere other than a full race weekend or an authorised testing session.
 
Back
Top Bottom