Poll The New Sound

The 2014 engine sound - select all that apply

  • I like it

    Votes: 29 45.3%
  • I will get used to it

    Votes: 34 53.1%
  • I hate it

    Votes: 5 7.8%
  • Something must be done to improve it

    Votes: 7 10.9%
  • I agree that change was necessary

    Votes: 9 14.1%
  • The sound of F1 is important to my enjoyment

    Votes: 21 32.8%

  • Total voters
    64

jez101

Bookies drive nice cars because of people like me
Contributor
Ok, so what do we think?

People don't like change. Having said that, the argument for change is strong: civilisation needs to use less energy.

But has F1 thrown the baby out with the bathwater? The sound of the cars has changed radically, will we get used to it? Do we have to just suck up and deal with it? Should the sport mandate that cars all carry loudspeakers to bring it back? What would you do?
 

F1Yorkshire

Avatar for sale to the highest bidder
Contributor
The only practical way to improve the sound would be something like the attached pic.

The quiet is strange but will get used to it. What I do like are the additional noises that were always hidden. The tyre noises have been epic so far!

big bore nova.jpg
 

Lew_beauty

Rookie
The vast majority of F1 fans watch most of the races on TV. When watching F1 on TV the engines are mostly background noise. It's nice to hear the cars shifting and revving, but you can hear that even clearer now, in my opinion. So I would say that people are making too much of a big deal over this. I think if you asked most people now if they wished we could go back to F1 2013 vs what we've had today, I think they'd vote for the new cars as a whole. People will always see the negatives in these things.

I also don't get it from a petrol head POV. I'm not a petrol head as much as I am a sports fan, but this is the most interested I've been in how the cars work. They're so much more advanced and complex now. So much more is going on and the engineers have so much more to get on top of. We've had stagnation for quite a few years now when it comes to the engines. I want to embrace the new. When it comes to watching F1 on TV, the sound of the cars is one of these things you only notice when it is taken away.
 
Last edited:

tooncheese

Hans Heyer
Contributor
I don't mind the pitch, and other whistles, but it's just so quiet, makes me think that there is a lot more power to be had, but the engineers weren't allowed too due to the various regulations. It's like they have michelin star chefs competing to make the best casserole.
 

rufus_mcdufus

Champion Elect
I like it. I'm finding it easier to differentiate between engine noises already. Something sounded very odd, like an angry man growling! Think it was the Ferrari engine.
 

Bill Boddy

Professional layabout
Contributor
I've said it before, the greatest place for sound was the exit of Bridge at Silverstone. The sound was mostly masked until just before the cars appeared, then there was a blast as they went hurtling past you.

There have been many changes of sound during the lifetime of F1, from the low pitched power sound of the early cars through the banshee howl of the BRM H16 to the high pitched scream of recent years. We will get used to it.
 

Titch

Champion Elect
Premium Contributor
I still think they sound like a load of superbikes, maybe not even as powerful as that, but I don't much care really.
 

Fenderman

Rooters Reporter
Voted for the last option and I'd like to hear how people are perceiving the issue from track-side. What I heard on a Sky feed wasn't very good but on the Beeb highlights show I could hear the cars a lot better and I like the fact that they sound different to each other. It's also interesting to hear the turbo sounds and tyres squealing.

The main problem is the sound engineers who mix down the sound sources have the balance too far in favour of the commentators. The Beeb did a much better mix - something they have always been better at in my view. Wotsisname screaming his head off in the Sky commentary box drowned out all the ambient sounds from the circuit - something he has always been far too good at. The sound engineers need educating that the ambient sounds, particularly the noises from the cars on track, give us punters a flavour of the atmosphere of the event. Over excited and excessively loud commentators detract from that.
 
Top Bottom