No Favouritism at McLaren, either!

Brogan and Danby ask relevant and important questions about Button's qualifying and his use of tyres, respectively.

And the answer is very much, directly under these spot-lights.

Button's highly acclaimed 'smoothness' is a natural driving style, for him. It is how he has learned - throughout his career; and how he has come to maximise his own performance. It is his own, instinctive way of driving a car, much as it was for Damon Hill and, to some extent Alain Prost.

One of the reasons Button tends to experience less 'graining' of his tyres, is the way he gradually heats them up (relative to most of the other drivers). And, as a rule, this helps their longevity. But the down-side of this compromise, is that his natural style does not generate heat quickly. And with today's qualifying format, it is important to be able to get the tyres up to an optimum temperature very quickly.

In a sense then, Button is at a natural disadvantage for qualifying, but can quite reasonably expect to off-set this during the length of a race - at the very least! The reason is that when his tyres are up to temperature, he can string together many very quick laps, with almost metronomic consistency, as a direct result of his ultra-smooth style.
 
cosicave said:
Brogan and Danby ask relevant and important questions about Button's qualifying and his use of tyres, respectively.

And the answer is very much, directly under these spot-lights.

Button's highly acclaimed 'smoothness' is a natural driving style, for him. It is how he has learned - throughout his career; and how he has come to maximise his own performance. It is his own, instinctive way of driving a car, much as it was for Damon Hill and, to some extent Alain Prost.

One of the reasons Button tends to experience less 'graining' of his tyres, is the way he gradually heats them up (relative to most of the other drivers). And, as a rule, this helps their longevity. But the down-side of this compromise, is that his natural style does not generate heat quickly. And with today's qualifying format, it is important to be able to get the tyres up to an optimum temperature very quickly.

In a sense then, Button is at a natural disadvantage for qualifying, but can quite reasonably expect to off-set this during the length of a race - at the very least! The reason is that when his tyres are up to temperature, he can string together many very quick laps, with almost metronomic consistency, as a direct result of his ultra-smooth style.

The problem for Button is, of course, that you do need to be good in all sessions to challenge the team-mate he's got, who is excellent, and will highlight any weakness if he's allowed to. Ask Kovalainen!
 
teabagyokel said:
…The problem for Button is, of course, that you do need to be good in all sessions to challenge the team-mate he's got, who is excellent, and will highlight any weakness if he's allowed to. Ask Kovalainen![/font]
Yes… Absolutely! I agree.

I didn't really want to get into the over-done debate of a direct comparison of these two, but in a thread such as this, I am going to allow myself a moment of weakness:
I believe Hamilton has enough talent to overcome my attempt at an objective assessment of Button (above).
I also believe that Button knows this. There! - That might put the cat amongst the pigeons!

P.S. I am not a 'fan' of any driver, and have no personal axe to grind here. It's just the way I see it.
That said, I must confess a personal interest which would likely show itself as bias, which I think would be unethical.
 
cosicave said:
I believe Hamilton has enough talent to overcome my attempt at an objective assessment of Button (above).
I also believe that Button knows this.

I think they all know where they stand in comparison to drivers like Alonso/Hamilton and maybe Vettel in coming years, even if some of them don't want to admit it!
 
teabagyokel said:
cosicave said:
I believe Hamilton has enough talent to overcome my attempt at an objective assessment of Button (above).
I also believe that Button knows this.
I think they all know where they stand in comparison to drivers like Alonso/Hamilton and maybe Vettel in coming years, even if some of them don't want to admit it!
Perhaps. But it is clearer with some than others.

Now, having let my guard down - , I'll come out with another salvo: Button is right up there at the top.

For a subject such as this, I believe it is only relevant to speak of the present and the immediate future, so…
To me, Button's 'clear head' puts him above Alonso and Vettel, even if his car is still lagging behind them.

But we need to remain 'on-topic', so, if you'll excuse me, I'd prefer to say no more on the matter here.
 
If this needs to go somewhere else, please remove it, BUT.... I don't understand some peoples 'acceptance', or resigning to the fact that Lewis is faster than Jenson? That's just not true IMO, and there is only perhaps two places this year we have seen them in a position to compare. I think peoples evaluation of Jensons qualifying performance is interesting and probably very close to correct or the truth. However, Jensons in-race pace (which its actually all about IMO) is second to none.

He has set fastest laps, as has Lewis and he has impressed me more than i expected against Lewis i will admit.

There are parts of Lewis' skill set that are unique to him, being able to drive just about anything, flat out, as has been mentioned is one such and also the aforementioned re-overtake move on Jenson is another, but Jensons tyre saving and good decision making are just as valuable, and again almost unique skills. I think in the races, there is nothing between those two drivers and if we get them on the same piece of tarmac at the same time (ie similar qualifying) we will see a very close fought battle.

Can someone please argue against me and tell me why they think I'm wrong, and actually Lewis IS just faster, or 'better' ?? because as much as i expected it pre-season, i don't see it on Sundays.

Credit to you Jenson! even if Lewis is my favourite driver :) and good job McLaren for not being dragged down by some stupid scandal of driver favouritism!
 
For what it's worth Grizzly, I'm with you there.

I think if qualifying were not an intrinsic part of the whole thing, the general assessment of Button would be even higher, further reducing or perhaps nullifying any perceived differences between himself and the other guy…
 
MajorDanby said:
...it should benefit Jenson who has aways enjoyed a stable rear end.

I guess any people would say Hamilton prefers the rear end moving about more...
Maybe someone should ask Jessica and Nicole for their opinions...

:whistle:
 
Any comparison of race laps and the drawing of conclusions is as slippery as comparing Friday morning testing times. As it takes no account of being in clear air, stuck behind a slower car(usually MS), catching traffic etc. However if Jenson's smoother driving style gives him an advantage over a race distance the race lap analysis charts paint a clear and concise picture. Lewis's lap times during and at the end of stints are as consistent, as fast if not faster than Jenson's. There is no discrepancy or tell tale drop off in lap time that indicates Lewis losing performance relative to Jenson.

In Canada where tyres were an issue we can see that at no time did Jenson have an edge over Lewis:
1 J. BUTTON____________2 L. HAMILTON
1 12:04:38____________1 12:04:35
2 1:24.132____________2 1:22.636
3 1:23.636____________3 1:22.109
4 1:22.692____________4 1:21.794
5 1:23.981____________5 1:22.302
6 1:37.274 P _________6 1:23.578
7 1:22.277____________7 1:39.497 P
8 1:21.464____________8 1:23.540
9 1:22.365____________9 1:20.574
10 1:21.317____________10 1:20.273
11 1:19.845____________11 1:20.054
12 1:19.808____________12 1:20.583
13 1:19.907____________13 1:20.455
14 1:20.090____________14 1:20.937
15 1:20.769____________15 1:21.658
16 1:20.839____________16 1:20.566
17 1:20.638____________17 1:20.537
18 1:20.677____________18 1:20.234
19 1:20.453____________19 1:20.452
20 1:20.634____________20 1:20.583
21 1:20.673____________21 1:20.713
22 1:20.746____________22 1:21.117
23 1:20.470____________23 1:20.776
24 1:20.445____________24 1:20.626
25 1:21.184____________25 1:20.665
26 1:20.445____________26 1:34.836 P
27 1:33.736 P_________ 27 1:21.130
28 1:21.493____________28 1:19.161
29 1:20.640____________29 1:20.114
30 1:20.610____________30 1:20.401
31 1:20.241____________31 1:20.198
32 1:20.264____________32 1:20.237
33 1:19.701____________33 1:19.532
34 1:19.835____________34 1:19.787
35 1:19.554____________35 1:19.659
36 1:19.558____________36 1:19.361
37 1:19.021____________37 1:19.208
38 1:19.332____________38 1:18.868
39 1:19.520____________39 1:18.810
40 1:19.263____________40 1:19.512
41 1:19.149____________41 1:19.458
42 1:19.683____________42 1:19.375
43 1:19.089____________43 1:18.923
44 1:18.757____________44 1:19.012
45 1:18.693____________45 1:18.879
46 1:18.903____________46 1:19.344
47 1:19.795____________47 1:18.740
48 1:19.935____________48 1:19.095
49 1:18.734____________49 1:20.175
50 1:19.016____________50 1:19.132
51 1:18.732____________51 1:19.103
52 1:18.839____________52 1:18.996
53 1:18.931____________53 1:19.479
54 1:19.189____________54 1:19.281
55 1:19.498____________55 1:19.306
56 1:19.296____________56 1:19.264
57 1:18.872____________57 1:19.420
58 1:18.829____________58 1:19.017
59 1:18.331____________59 1:18.958
60 1:18.313____________60 1:18.456
61 1:18.365____________61 1:18.025
62 1:18.758____________62 1:17.806
63 1:18.214____________63 1:17.989
64 1:18.411____________64 1:18.134
65 1:18.191____________65 1:18.227
66 1:18.144____________66 1:18.492
67 1:18.155____________67 1:18.428
68 1:18.317____________68 1:18.174
69 1:18.526____________69 1:18.809
70 1:19.633____________70 1:20.519

This picture is repeated at just about every GP this season, Jenson's smooth style doesn't appear to give him any advantage in longevity over Lewis's more creative style.
 
Wee Scot said:
MajorDanby said:
...it should benefit Jenson who has aways enjoyed a stable rear end.

I guess any people would say Hamilton prefers the rear end moving about more...
Maybe someone should ask Jessica and Nicole for their opinions...

:whistle:

Is that what they are calling their race engineers? :dunno:
 
cosicave said:
For a subject such as this, I believe it is only relevant to speak of the present and the immediate future, so…
To me, Button's 'clear head' puts him above Alonso and Vettel, even if his car is still lagging behind them.

I feel I would trust Alonso to drive a car faster than Button if everything is in equilibrium, but in life sometimes you have problems, and I feel Alonso has no mechanism to cope with them.

Grizzly said:
BUT.... I don't understand some peoples 'acceptance', or resigning to the fact that Lewis is faster than Jenson? That's just not true IMO, and there is only perhaps two places this year we have seen them in a position to compare. I think peoples evaluation of Jensons qualifying performance is interesting and probably very close to correct or the truth. However, Jensons in-race pace (which its actually all about IMO) is second to none.

I'm not stating that Hamilton is faster than anyone (bar Nelsinho Piquet). I feel, however, that the way the system currently works is of great benefit to Hamilton's superior qualifying pace. If you had a 'superpole' system where you did 10-20 laps in succession to qualify for a Grand Prix, I would take Button any day!

So I would agree with your sentiments. Remember, in praising Hamilton I am never trying to slight Button. Both are excellent drivers, both lead the championship from guys in a better car. I feel that Hamilton will probably come out on top. But I would never describe X being faster than Y as a 'fact' (unless Y is Nelsinho Piquet). It is all transitory.
 
The Mclaren is designed to suit Lewis' ragged driving style, which I why I don't think Jenson can quite get the best out of the machinery. The last couple of seasons the cars were designed to minimise Hamilton's tyre wearing problems. I think the way they did it was to have the rear tyres heat up very quickly so that they didn't wear by being cold for long. This suited Lewis' style as he likes the car to thrash around a bit at the back and so the tyres would heat up. However, because Kovalainen has a smooth driving style, he found that the 08 and 09 Mclaren's rear tyres would overheat and so he would, paradoxically, suffer from tyre degradation more than he should have done. Don't hold me to that but I'm pretty sure that was how it went.

This year's car was designed with Lewis' style in mind - Mclaren started it well before the end of last season while Jenson wasn't signed until the design process was well under way. This may partly explain his qualifying woes.

We may see next year's Mclaren being a little more to Button's liking than the MP4-25 (I think that's the chassis anyway :))
 
Using snowy's data (well, the FIA's data really), here's a line chart of the lap times.

Make of it what you will.

[Click image to view full size]
 

Attachments

  • ButvHamLaps.png
    ButvHamLaps.png
    26.9 KB · Views: 80
snowy said:
Wee Scot said:
MajorDanby said:
...it should benefit Jenson who has aways enjoyed a stable rear end.

I guess any people would say Hamilton prefers the rear end moving about more...
Maybe someone should ask Jessica and Nicole for their opinions...

:whistle:

Is that what they are calling their race engineers? :dunno:
Actually, those characterizations would seem to fit Jessica and Nicole "to a T" (for thong, perhaps?), since the former has made her living from still photos, while the latter rakes in the cash by shakin' it!

ROFL
 
Back
Top Bottom